Narratively Academy

Narratively Academy

StoryCraft 🛠️

How to Listen to Your Inner Editorial Voices (All of Them)

…and how to let each and every one of them do their authentic “job.”

Caroline Rothstein's avatar
Caroline Rothstein
May 06, 2026
∙ Paid

As a writer across genres—and a creative writing, poetry, and journalism educator and instructor—I know that editing is a gift. And yet, sometimes, I think there’s something wrong with me when I need to edit my own work. The fact that I didn’t manage to beget the perfect draft out the gate? It feels like a fail.

In my heart, I know that’s not true. But here’s the thing. Sometimes I do write something that comes out immaculate at first go. But that’s not the rule. Lately I’ve been pondering: How can we appreciate—and know—our unique inner editorial voices in helping us strengthen our work?

I have come to think of editing my own work as a conglomeration of multiple editorial voices. And I believe we all have at least three, a trifecta council on whom our editorial skills rest:

  • a “knowing” voice

  • a “diagnostic” voice

  • a “worker bee” voice

Together, they lovingly work in tandem to co-create our strongest work by relinquishing judgment and doubt. The key is figuring out how to let these three voic…

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Narratively · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture